Rent vs Buy Calculator
Compare the long-term financial outcomes of renting vs buying. See how property growth, investment returns, and ongoing costs affect your wealth over time.
Compare Renting vs Buying
Property Details
Rental & Growth Assumptions
🏠 Buying Scenario
🏢 Renting Scenario
Wealth Comparison Over Time
Cost Breakdown
Buying Costs
Renting Costs
As a renter, you invest the deposit + stamp duty upfront, plus the difference between buying costs and rent each month into a diversified investment portfolio.
Year-by-Year Comparison
| Year | Property Value | Loan Balance | Buy Equity | Rent Portfolio | Better Option |
|---|
The 5% Rule Analysis
Understanding the Rent vs Buy Decision
The rent vs buy decision is one of the biggest financial choices Australians face. While home ownership is deeply ingrained in Australian culture, it's not always the best financial decision—especially in high-cost cities.
The True Cost of Buying
Buying a home involves costs that renters don't face:
- Stamp duty: 3-5.5% of purchase price (varies by state)
- Conveyancing: $1,500-$3,000
- Building/pest inspection: $500-$1,000
- Lenders Mortgage Insurance: $10,000-$50,000 (if deposit <20%)
- Ongoing: Council rates, insurance, maintenance (1-2% of property value annually)
- Interest payments: Typically 60-70% of payments in early years
The Renter's Advantage
Renters who invest the difference between renting costs and owning costs can build significant wealth through diversified investments. Key advantages:
- Lower upfront costs (no deposit, stamp duty)
- Investment diversification (not all wealth in one asset)
- Flexibility to move for career opportunities
- No maintenance or repair responsibilities
- Lower risk (property values can fall)
When Buying Usually Wins
- You plan to stay 7+ years in the same location
- Property growth exceeds 4% annually
- You value stability and home ownership lifestyle
- You're disciplined about mortgage payments (forced savings)
- You have a 20% deposit (avoid LMI)
When Renting Usually Wins
- You may relocate within 5 years
- Rent is significantly below equivalent mortgage payments
- You're disciplined about investing the savings
- Property market is overvalued relative to rents
- You value flexibility over stability
Stamp Duty by State (2024-25)
| State | $500,000 Property | $750,000 Property | $1,000,000 Property | First Home Buyer Concession |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| NSW | $17,990 | $29,240 | $40,490 | Full exemption up to $800K |
| VIC | $21,970 | $31,070 | $55,000 | Full exemption up to $600K |
| QLD | $15,925 | $26,775 | $38,025 | Concession up to $550K |
| WA | $17,765 | $29,390 | $42,615 | Full exemption up to $430K |
| SA | $21,330 | $34,580 | $48,830 | Full exemption up to $650K (new) |
| TAS | $18,247 | $28,935 | $42,996 | 50% discount up to $600K |
| NT | $23,928 | $37,678 | $52,303 | $18,601 rebate |
| ACT | $11,400 | $22,100 | $34,900 | Full exemption (income tested) |
Note: Rates are approximate and may vary. Always check with your state revenue office for exact calculations.